Understanding the implications of out-of-stocks of key products in retail

‍

Out-of-stock (OOS) situations – when a product a consumer intends to buy is unavailable – pose a significant challenge in the retail industry. For key products, which often serve as traffic drivers or category anchors, OOS can have a disproportionate impact on customer satisfaction, brand loyalty, and retailer profitability. This article explores the causes and implications of such stock-outs, supported by referenced research and industry data.

‍

1. Definition and scale of the problem

Out-of-stocks occur when products are unavailable on the shelf or online at the point of purchase. According to a comprehensive report by the Grocery Manufacturers Association (GMA), the average OOS rate in retail is about 8%, and can rise to 10% or more during promotions or peak seasons.

Key products – defined as items that drive high volume, have high velocity of sales, or are strategically important to a retailer – make stock-outs particularly harmful due to their role in consumer purchase decisions.

‍

2. Causes of out-of-stocks

Research conducted by Gruen, Corsten, and Bharadwaj (2002) identified three primary causes for OOS:

• In-store operations (32%): Failures in replenishment, misplacement of stock, or shelf restocking delays.
• Store ordering (15%): Inaccurate demand forecasting or improper ordering cycles.
• Supply chain issues (53%): Supplier delays, production shortages, or logistical breakdowns.

Disruptions from macroeconomic shocks, such as the COVID-19 pandemic or geopolitical conflicts, also exacerbate these issues by straining global supply chains and causing shortages in raw materials and labor.

‍

3. Consumer reactions and retail impact

According to research from Harvard Business Review, when faced with an OOS situation, consumers typically respond in the following ways:

• Substitution (70%): Choose an alternative product, often leading to brand-switching.
• Store-switching (15%): Go to a different retailer to find the product.
• Postponement or abandonment (15%): Delay or abandon the purchase altogether.

The same study indicated that out-of-stocks can reduce customer satisfaction by up to 30% and may lead to long-term erosion of brand loyalty, particularly for products considered essential or habitual.

‍

4. Financial and strategic implications for retailers

Retailers suffer direct and indirect financial losses due to OOS:

• Lost sales revenue: Nielsen estimates that U.S. retailers lose up to 93 billion dollars annually due to out-of-stocks.
• Shrinkage of market share: Persistent key product OOS situations can result in lost share to competitors who maintain better availability.
• Brand perception: Frequent stock-outs, particularly of staple or high-demand products, damage brand equity and signal operational inefficiencies.

Additionally, stock-outs during promotional periods (e.g., Black Friday or product launches) undermine marketing investments and distort sales forecasts.

‍

5. Predictive value of stock-outs

Stock-outs of key products can also signal deeper strategic issues:

• Demand misjudgment: A consistent OOS pattern may indicate poor demand planning or failure to adjust to market trends.
• Supply chain vulnerability: Repeated disruptions hint at fragility in sourcing or distribution networks.
• Operational bottlenecks: High OOS rates can reveal inefficiencies in store-level execution or inventory management systems.

In some cases, stock-outs may even be used strategically (this is known as "engineered scarcity”) to create urgency or perceived product desirability. However, this approach is risky and may backfire if not carefully managed.

‍

6. Mitigation strategies

Retailers can mitigate the risk and impact of stock-outs through several proven strategies:

• Improved forecasting: Leveraging machine learning and historical data to enhance demand prediction accuracy.
• Real-time inventory management: Using RFID and IoT to track stock levels and automate replenishment.
• Omnichannel integration: Allowing customers to access inventory across physical and digital channels.
• Collaborative planning: Strengthening supplier-retailer relationships through CPFR (collaborative planning, forecasting, and replenishment) models.

‍

Out-of-stocks of key products remain a critical issue in retail, with far-reaching implications for sales, brand loyalty, and operational efficiency. Understanding the underlying causes and consumer reactions is essential for designing effective mitigation strategies. With the continued evolution of supply chain technologies and data analytics, retailers have a growing toolbox to reduce OOS incidents and maintain customer trust.

‍

References:

Buzek, G. (2018). Out of stocks, out of luck. IHL Group.
https://www.radial.com/files/2022/06/out-of-stock-solutions.pdf
Corsten, D., Gruen, T.W. (2004). Stockouts cause walkouts. Harvard Business Review.
https://hbr.org/2004/05/stock-outs-cause-walkouts
Gruen, T.W., Corsten, D. (2007). A comprehensive guide to retail out-of-stock reduction in the fast-moving consumer goods industry. FMI, GMA, NACDS.
https://www.nacds.org/pdfs/membership/out_of_stock.pdf
Gruen, T.W., Corsten, D., & Bharadwaj, S. (2002). Retail out-of-stocks: A worldwide examination of extent, causes and consumer responses. GMA, FMI, CIES – The Food Business Forum.
https://www.supplychain247.com/images/pdfs/GMA_2002_Worldwide_OOS_Study.pdf

‍